Recently, news broke that Spanish coach Roberto Moreno was sacked by Russian club FC Sochi after managing only 7 games. Adding to the shock, allegations surfaced that he used ChatGPT for advice on player transfers. This news has caused a stir among Korean football fans, as Moreno was once considered a candidate for the South Korea national team head coach position. In hindsight, the Korea Football Association (KFA) did not appoint him, and this situation is being viewed as a narrowly avoided potential issue for Korean football.
Moreno's case raises fundamental questions about the role and decision-making processes of modern football managers. His poor record—being fired after just seven matches—clearly indicates his failure to manage the team effectively. Common reasons for quick dismissals typically involve severe performance declines or irreparable rifts between the coach, players, or board members. In Moreno's situation, beyond poor performance, the focus has shifted to the improper use of judgment tools in recruitment.
Tactically speaking, player recruitment is one of the key elements that shape a team's strategic identity and future. A coach must integrate their football philosophy with the team’s current standing and the league's characteristics to determine necessary positions and player types, rather than simply evaluating individual stats or market value. It involves an in-depth analysis of a player's potential, tactical understanding, team chemistry, and adaptability to the team’s culture. This process requires a considerable amount of match observation, scouting report review, and direct interactions, emphasizing the importance of human insight and experience.
While AI tools like ChatGPT might excel at analyzing large volumes of data and identifying patterns, football involves countless variables, emotions, and human factors that cannot be fully captured by straightforward data. For instance, understanding whether a player’s style fits the team dynamics, assessing the intensity required, and evaluating leadership in crisis are realities AI cannot fully grasp or address entirely. Particularly, the subtle psychological states of players, locker room atmosphere, and the 'invisible values' that a coach seeks are aspects that AI, at present, cannot comprehend or advise upon.
The Korean Football Association’s decision in this scenario is noteworthy. When Moreno was considered for the national team, many evaluations were made regarding his tactical capabilities and leadership. In retrospect, not choosing him proved to be a wise and crucial decision for South Korea's football. Although the controversy over the use of ChatGPT wasn’t known at the time, it’s likely that the association’s technical committee made a well-rounded judgment based on various aspects like Moreno’s tactical vision, squad management skills, and understanding of Korean football.
This incident reiterates the essential competencies modern football managers must possess. While data analysis and cutting-edge technology usage are significant, it’s the manager's human insight, leadership, and experience-informed judgment that truly lead a team to success. It’s not merely about compiling information but interpreting and applying it within a football context, a domain that remains uniquely within human managers’ reach. Though AI’s role in football will continue to expand, its usage should primarily assist, not replace, human judgment. Ultimately, victories are determined by players’ passion and the manager’s profound understanding and decision-making.
@RobertoMoreno @FCSochi @KoreanFootballAssociation @ChatGPT @FootballNews